Menu
  • Home
  • About
    • Contact
      • Subscribe
      • Close
    • Close
  • In Season
    • Basketball
    • MMA
    • Running
    • Soccer
    • Close
  • Pro
  • Olympics
  • College
  • High School
  • Youth
  • Coaching
  • Business
  • Title IX
  • Entertainment
  • Inspiration

Women Talk Sports

Women's Sports News and Commentary

You are here: Home / SportsPLUS / Discrimination/Title IX / What should we take from Miller’s firing?

December 18, 2014 By Title IX Blog Leave a Comment

What should we take from Miller’s firing?

This post will start cynical (it has not been a great week for discrimination against women in sports) but I will try to end on an up(ish) note.

So we can now add to the list of things that will get female coaches fired/dismissed/forced into retirement: having too high of a salary. This joins such explanations (which range in legitimacy-I’m not commenting on whether or not they are true, just that they have been offered in some suspect dismissals): having a family, not having a family, pulling a player’s shirt, banning white bread, reporting gender inequity, yelling at players, being too feminine, not being feminine enough, too successful, not successful enough.

University of Minnesota Duluth women’s hockey head coach Shannon Miller, who coached her team to five NCAA championships, was told this week that her contract is not being renewed (she will finish out the season) because her salary-the highest of any head women’s hockey coach at $215,000-is too high for the financially distressed UMD to sustain. Most of those reasons above are never applied to male coaches (yes, Tim Rice at Rutgers-who was caught on videotape-is an exception and lack of success is often a reason male coaches get bought out of their contracts)-but certainly “we’re paying you too much, so we have to let you go” is something male coaches do not hear when they are sat down in the athletic director’s office to be fired.

This incident cannot be looked at in isolation. Don’t forget the story from just a few weeks ago out of Iowa and the apparent pattern of female coaches being fired, not renewed, or entering into early retirement.

Yes, UMD is a different school, this is a different rationale, but it is part of the pattern. We may not know exactly what the pattern is and, unfortunately, I suspect the number of smoking guns that exist to explain things are rare-because I don’t believe there is one thing that makes an athletic department fire female coaches. It’s about the power of male administrators, beliefs about female leadership, the value of women’s sports, the value of female coaches, and so much more.

Though this story broke two days ago, I feel we are a little bit behind given the extensive news coverage. But-and here is the potential upside-doubts are being raised and questions are being asked. Dr. Nicole LaVoi of University of Minnesota has been speaking to the media and also posted on her blog, One Sport Voice, some revealing data about coaching, salaries, and discrimination.

UMD made a mistake not just in firing Miller but in providing a weak justification, which only serves to make people question the actual justification. They also made a mistake in doing it so close to the revelations about what is happening at Iowa. And they underestimated a general public that dislikes overt discrimination. It may be difficult to see and understand structures and systems of discrimination, but it is not hard to see that firing a female coach under the guise of being paid too much when there are other, less successful male coaches who are paid more…well that’s gender discrimination.

Powered by Sidelines

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr

Related

Filed Under: Discrimination/Title IX, Ice Hockey, Sports, SportsPLUS

What’s Popular:

  • Project WISH looks to bring positive growth to women's ice sledge hockey
    Project WISH looks to bring positive growth to women's ice sledge hockey
  • Tennis' Top Females Dress Up For WTA Istanbul Draw Ceremony
  • High quality of play the defining theme of 2015 CBHA Nationals
    High quality of play the defining theme of 2015 CBHA Nationals
  • Weekend Report - Emily Peters-Kagan Snaps Glena Avila's Undefeated Streak; Tiffany Van Soest Gains WBC Belt
  • Scandalous WNBA transactions
    Scandalous WNBA transactions

Speak up! Leave a Comment: Cancel reply

Around the Web

The latest headlines from around the web.

Flanagan sets American 10K road record in Holland

September 7, 2015 3:57 pm

Serena Williams’ Slam bid runs into Keys

September 6, 2015 4:42 pm

Infeld Euphoric, Huddle Devastated After World Champs 10K

August 25, 2015 2:18 am

Jen Welter Makes History As First Female NFL Coach via @realstylenet

July 28, 2015 3:54 pm

Anna van der Breggen wins rain-soaked La Course by Le Tour de France

July 26, 2015 3:29 pm

Subscribe to our e-Newsletter

We'll send you the best headlines from women's sports, no more than once a week, and we'll never share your information with third parties.

Ashley Caldwell nails the triple, wins Freestyle Aerials at World Cup

The Latest in Women’s Sports:

How small teams get to big championships

September 7, 2015 By real girl sport Leave a Comment

One spot left as Sparks, Liberty seal deals

September 7, 2015 By Sue Favor Leave a Comment

Project WISH looks to bring positive growth to women’s ice sledge hockey

September 7, 2015 By Mark Thibert Staffieri Leave a Comment

Self defense: Liberty’s defense is opponents objection

September 7, 2015 By Kat LaRocca Leave a Comment

Just some facts and opinions

September 6, 2015 By Sarah and Jessica Leave a Comment

Pretty Tough
TwitterFacebookLinkedinYoutubegoogleplus

Sports:

Menu
    • Action
    • Baseball
    • Basketball
    • Boardsports
    • Boxing
    • Cycling
    • Equestrian
    • Field Hockey
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Gymnastics
    • Ice Hockey
    • Lacrosse
    • Men's Sports
    • MMA
    • More
    • Motorsports
    • Muay Thai
    • Multisport
    • Olympics
    • Racquetball
    • Roller Derby
    • Rugby
    • Running
    • Skating
    • Soccer
    • Softball
    • Swimming
    • Tennis
    • Track & Field
    • Volleyball
    • Watersports
    • Weightlifting
    • Wintersports
    • Wrestling

Sports PLUS:

Menu
    • Anti-Doping
    • Awards
    • Blogderby
    • Business
    • Career
    • Cause/Charity
    • Coaching
    • Discrimination/Title IX
    • Eating Disorders
    • Entertainment
    • Events
    • Family/Parenting
    • Fans
    • Fantasy Sports
    • Fashion
    • Fun Stuff
    • Gear & Equipment
    • Health & Fitness
    • History
    • Injuries
    • Inspiration
    • International/World
    • LGBT
    • Masters
    • Media/Marketing
    • NCAA
    • OpEd
    • Personal
    • Politics
    • Psychology
    • Racism
    • Research
    • Rules of the Game
    • Sexism
    • Sponsorship
    • Sportsmanship
    • Student-Athlete
    • Technology
    • Training
    • Transgender

Home · Legal · Contact · Copyright Women Talk Sports, LLC© 2015 · Log in

Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.